Brotherhood of Thieves
Known For
Classic chowder served in a garden courtyard with genuine Downtown character
Brotherhood of Thieves has been anchoring Downtown Nantucket for long enough that its garden vibes outdoor seating and instagrammable atmosphere feel earned rather than engineered. Order the chowder, find a table outside, and settle in.
🕐Best time to visit: weekday lunch in August when the garden seats open up
Our Take
Brotherhood of Thieves has the relaxed, sun-dappled patio energy that makes a weekend brunch feel like a full event rather than just a meal — and nearly a thousand ratings confirm this isn't a fluke. It's a genuine local standout with the kind of no-rush vibe that keeps people coming back.
The Vibe
FindCuteSpots Original
✦ Cute Score ✦
Location
Downtown
23 Broad St, Nantucket, MA 02554, USA
✦ Free Weekly Dispatch
Love spots like this? Get hidden gems delivered to your inbox every Tuesday.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
More spots like this
The Nautilus
The Nautilus turns weekend brunch into something worth dressing up for, with floral decor spilling into an outdoor seating area that catches the morning light…
The Proprietors Bar & Table
The Proprietors Bar & Table flows from a bright & airy interior out to outdoor seating with genuine garden vibes, making it one of Nantucket's most complete…
The Rose and Crown
The Rose and Crown earns its instagrammable reputation through a genuinely romantic courtyard where garden vibes meet candlelit corners. Bring someone you want…
Straight Wharf Restaurant
Straight Wharf Restaurant puts you directly at the edge of the harbor, with outdoor seating that makes every plate feel more festive and garden vibes softening…
Crosswinds Restaurant
Crosswinds Restaurant is a local favorite that leans into outdoor seating and garden vibes with a bright and airy interior waiting for when the weather turns.…
Easy Street Restaurant
Easy Street Restaurant leans into its garden vibes and outdoor seating hard enough to make a sunny Nantucket morning feel like the whole point of being there.…
The Tree Bar
At The Tree Bar, the garden vibes are literal — tables arranged around mature trees make the outdoor seating feel like a private grove rather than a bar patio.…
Brant Point Grill
Brant Point Grill earns its instagrammable tag honestly — the bright and airy harborside setting, floral decor, and water views conspire to make every table…
Is this your business? Claim or edit this listing — we'll get back to you within 24 hours.