Back to Sag Harbor
Brunch Spots·Downtown·Sag Harbor, NY

Captain Jack's On The Coast

4.7Google rating(132 reviews)
Captain Jack's On The Coast

Known For

Waterfront tables with unobstructed sky and sea light

Captain Jack's On The Coast earns its local favorite status with bright & airy waterside energy and a menu that doesn't overthink itself. The instagrammable views do the heavy lifting, but the food holds its own.

🕐Best time to visit: When the tide is high and the afternoon is slow

1109 Noyack Rd, Southampton, NY 11968, USA

Our Take

Captain Jack's has the easygoing coastal energy of a place that hasn't tried too hard and doesn't need to — the food does the talking. It's a bright, locals-loved spot that earns a visit, particularly if you can snag a table when the light is right.

brunchSag Harbor, NY4.7 Google
Top 10 in Sag Harbor

FindCuteSpots Original

71/100

✦ Cute Score ✦

4.7Google rating
Open in Google Maps

Location

Downtown

1109 Noyack Rd, Southampton, NY 11968, USA

More spots in Sag Harbor

✦ Free Weekly Dispatch

Love spots like this? Get hidden gems delivered to your inbox every Tuesday.

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

More spots like this

Sen
48
Brunch4.2

Sen

Sen handles Sag Harbor's brunch crowd with a calm, bright & airy interior that somehow stays unhurried even when it's full. The instagrammable plating is a…

great for photosfloral decor
Le Bilboquet
44
Brunch3.7

Le Bilboquet

Le Bilboquet brings its floral decor and bright Parisian-brasserie energy to Sag Harbor with considerable flair — brunch here feels like a small occasion even…

great for photosfloral decor
Tutto il Giorno Sag
47
Brunch4.2

Tutto il Giorno Sag

Tutto il Giorno Sag delivers Italian-leaning brunch in a bright & airy room that spills onto one of the more pleasant stretches of outdoor seating in town.…

outdoor seatinggreat for photos
The Back Page
57
Brunch5.0

The Back Page

The Back Page's outdoor seating spills onto one of Sag Harbor's prettiest blocks, and the floral decor inside is bright enough to make even a gray morning feel…

outdoor seatinggreat for photos
DOPO La Spiaggia
54
Brunch4.3

DOPO La Spiaggia

DOPO La Spiaggia is where outdoor seating and garden vibes combine into the kind of Italian-inflected brunch that makes summer feel like it lasts forever. The…

bright & airyinstagrammable
Pierre's
45
Brunch3.9

Pierre's

Pierre's has held its corner of Sag Harbor with a relaxed garden-vibes outdoor terrace and a Gallic ease that makes brunch feel entirely unhurried. The local…

local favoritebright & airy
MONC XIII
75
Boutique4.8

MONC XIII

MONC XIII brings a bright & airy sensibility to Downtown Sag Harbor, with a charming storefront that draws you in before you've even checked the hours. Floral…

charming storefrontbright & airy
Urban Zen
59
Boutique4.5

Urban Zen

Urban Zen fills its bright, airy space with floral decor and a calm that makes shopping feel meditative rather than transactional — Donna Karan's philosophy…

bright & airyfloral decor

Is this your business? Claim or edit this listing — we'll get back to you within 24 hours.