Cookie Crush by Mayday
Known For
Thick, loaded cookies baked to order in small batches
Cookie Crush by Mayday occupies a cozy nook in Downtown St. Augustine with a charming storefront that signals exactly what's happening inside: serious cookies with a vintage interior backdrop that makes every shot look effortless. Come hungry, leave with extras.
🕐Best time to visit: When the afternoon bake comes out warm around 2 p.m.
Our Take
Cookie Crush by Mayday has the charming storefront, the cozy nook energy, and the vintage touches that make it visually compelling — and the pastries live up to the setting. Still building its reputation with a small but enthusiastic review base, making this a solid charming spot with room to climb.
FindCuteSpots Original
✦ Cute Score ✦
Location
Downtown
15 Hypolita St, St. Augustine, FL 32084, USA
✦ Free Weekly Dispatch
Love spots like this? Get hidden gems delivered to your inbox every Tuesday.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
More spots like this
Alms + Fare
Alms + Fare earns its charming storefront status the honest way — quality ingredients, a vintage interior that doesn't try too hard, and baked goods that…
LuLi's Cupcakes
LuLi's Cupcakes pairs a vintage interior with a bright, airy energy that makes every corner worth photographing — and every cupcake worth rotating for the…
Cedar Lakes Woods and Gardens
Cedar Lakes Woods and Gardens was hand-carved from a former rock quarry, and every cozy nook — from the floating islands to the grotto paths — reflects that…
Le Macaron
Le Macaron's St. Augustine outpost delivers the pastel, bright-and-airy aesthetic you'd expect from the brand — but the charming storefront on this block holds…
ChocoLattes
ChocoLattes earns its spot on any St. Augustine itinerary through a charming storefront and a vintage interior that feels genuinely lived-in rather than…
The Llambias House Garden
The Llambias House Garden is one of St. Augustine's most quietly extraordinary stops — a restored 18th-century courtyard with vintage interior details and lush…
BAR CITRA
BAR CITRA delivers a moody atmosphere with a vintage interior that photographs beautifully in low light — every corner feels considered without feeling staged.…
St. Augustine Alligator Farm Zoological Park
St. Augustine Alligator Farm Zoological Park has been operating since 1893, and its moody atmosphere of cypress canopy and vintage infrastructure gives it a…
Is this your business? Claim or edit this listing — we'll get back to you within 24 hours.