Lake Geneva Pie Co
Known For
Whole pies worth planning a visit — and a second slice — around
Lake Geneva Pie Co wraps its floral decor and cozy nook seating into a bright, welcoming space where the pies are the undisputed main character. It's exactly what a downtown bakery should feel like on a crisp afternoon.
🕐Best time to visit: November afternoons when seasonal flavors hit their stride
Our Take
Lake Geneva Pie Co wraps floral decor and cozy nook energy around a menu where the pies are clearly the main event — the kind of spot where you regret not ordering two slices. It's a solid charming stop with a loyal following, best visited when you have time to slow down and actually taste something.
The Vibe
FindCuteSpots Original
✦ Cute Score ✦
Location
Downtown
150 E Geneva Square, Lake Geneva, WI 53147, USA
✦ Free Weekly Dispatch
Love spots like this? Get hidden gems delivered to your inbox every Tuesday.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
More spots like this
Stinebrink’s Lake Geneva Piggly Wiggly
Stinebrink's Lake Geneva Piggly Wiggly punches well above its grocery-store expectations, with a bakery section that's become a genuine local favorite for…
Something Sweet- WE ARE NOW OPEN AGAIN AT OUR NEW LOCATION - 235 BROAD ST. DOWNTOWN LAKE GENEVA. COME SEE US!
Something Sweet brings genuine warmth to Broad Street with a bright & airy storefront dressed in floral decor that makes every visit feel like a small…
Oakfire
Oakfire brings bright & airy energy to Downtown Lake Geneva with floral touches that make every corner feel intentional. Weekend brunch here draws a crowd for…
The Getaway on Lake Como
The Getaway on Lake Como earns its name — floral decor, bright and airy rooms, and an instagrammable atmosphere that makes the whole visit feel like a mini…
Great Eggs
Great Eggs draws a steady crowd to its bright and airy dining room, where floral decor and great-for-photos outdoor seating make even a basic Benedict feel…
Flat Iron Tap
Flat Iron Tap punches well above its Downtown footprint — floral decor and bright & airy interiors create a brunch backdrop that's genuinely instagrammable…
Genevieve Lake Geneva
Genevieve Lake Geneva pairs instagrammable floral decor with a bright & airy layout that makes every corner worth photographing — and that's before you get to…
Grand Café
Grand Café spreads its floral decor across a bright and airy room that's drawn Lake Geneva regulars for years. It's a classic stop that trades on familiarity…
Is this your business? Claim or edit this listing — we'll get back to you within 24 hours.