Two Fat Cats Bakery
Known For
Legendary whoopie pies and fruit tarts inside a vintage pie-shop setting
Two Fat Cats Bakery occupies a vintage interior and charming storefront on India Street where the pie cases have been drawing serious attention since 2005. The whoopie pies are unimpeachable, but don't overlook the seasonal fruit tarts.
🕐Best time to visit: Late afternoon when the day's last pies are still warm
Our Take
Two Fat Cats Bakery leans hard into its vintage storefront character — pressed-tin ceilings, a cozy interior, and the kind of old-school bakery energy that feels increasingly rare. It's a charming neighborhood institution that rewards a visit without demanding one.
FindCuteSpots Original
✦ Cute Score ✦
Location
Downtown
195 Lancaster St, Portland, ME 04101, USA
✦ Free Weekly Dispatch
Love spots like this? Get hidden gems delivered to your inbox every Tuesday.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
More spots like this
Maine Historical Society and the Wadsworth-Longfellow House
The Maine Historical Society and Wadsworth-Longfellow House pairs a charming storefront facade with one of Portland's most genuinely interesting interiors —…
Letterpress Books & Gifts
Letterpress Books & Gifts occupies a charming storefront with exposed brick and a bright, airy interior that makes every visit feel like a small occasion. The…
Broadway Gardens Greenhouses Inc.
Broadway Gardens Greenhouses is the kind of charming storefront that smells incredible before you even open the door — warm, humid, and thick with blooms.…
Belleville
Belleville brings a French café sensibility to Portland through its charming storefront and bright & airy interior stocked with croissants, galettes, and the…
Deering Oaks Park
Deering Oaks Park carries a moody atmosphere that shifts with every season — fog-laced mornings, gold-lit afternoons, and that particular stillness you only…
Standard Baking Co
Standard Baking Co sets the bar for Portland's bakery scene from its charming storefront on Commercial Street, where the croissants rival anything you'd find…
Salt Yard Cafe & Bar
Salt Yard Cafe & Bar wears its vintage interior without irony — the warm wood, worn edges, and bright-and-airy windows create a Portland-perfect backdrop for a…
Yuri's Desserts
Yuri's Desserts occupies a bright & airy space where the vintage interior backdrop makes elaborate cakes and seasonal tarts look almost unfairly photogenic.…
Is this your business? Claim or edit this listing — we'll get back to you within 24 hours.